Dell Departs 8-way Server Market Segment Sun Exec Examines Dell's Motives, Finds Them Lacking
Dell has stepped out of the batter's box on the 8-way server market,
claiming that horizontally scaled entry-level servers will meet the needs
of its customers and announcing that the company will focus on 2-way and
4-way systems that its customers can cluster.
Souheil Saliba, vice president of Volume Server Product Marketing at Sun
questions the assumption behind Dell's decision to leave the 8-way
server market segment, asserting that there is a definite place for the
8-way server in commerce.
Saliba concedes that horizontally scaled entry-level servers might do
perfectly well as small, stateless and easily replicated systems
performing as Web servers, firewalls and media streaming systems,
especially since a farm of low-end servers can be had at attractive
prices. He argues that enterprise databases and such applications as
supply chain management systems call for the vertically scaled server
system, however. He points out that the slower external interconnects
in a horizontally scaled system cannot stand up to the high-speed
internal interconnects of a vertically scaled system. The cache
coherency necessary in enterprise settings is just not possible in a
horizontally scaled configuration, Saliba insists.
Even while Dell was an active player in the 8-processor server market,
Saliba points out that their success was far from assured. The older
Pentium III processor employed in the Dell 8-way server was, Saliba
maintains, not a hardy competitor against the better engineered, faster
processors that are part of the Sun FireTM V880 server.
No surprise, then, Saliba contends, that "while Dell retreats, the Sun
Fire V880 server continues to gain market share. Sun led the
8-processor server market segment, ending the first quarter of 2003
with 34.1 percent shipments market share, according to IDC's
Worldwide Quarterly Server Tracker. The 8- to 15-processor server market
segment continues to provide opportunity for growth. According to
IDC's Worldwide Quarterly Server Forecaster, IDC forecasts the
compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) for 8-processor to 15-processor
servers is expected to be 10.6 percent through 2007."
Instead of Dell's "one-size-fits-all" approach, Saliba stresses the
various server configurations available from Sun. According to Saliba,
"...Sun offers customers a wide range of systems -- from our
entry-level, x86-based Sun FireTM V60x server and Sun FireTM V65x
server, to our innovative blade platform, to our extremely powerful
106-way Sun FireTM 15K server -- that allow you to scale out or scale
up according to your needs. We also give you exceptional flexibility by
providing solutions that run the 32-bit SolarisTM Operating System
(Solaris OS) (x86 Platform Edition), the 64-bit Solaris OS, or various
flavors of Linux. As a result, you can optimize your computing
infrastructure by selecting the most appropriate server and operating
system based on the unique requirements of your diverse enterprise
applications."
Saliba asks his readers to consider whether Dell left "...the growing
8-way server space because one size truly does fit all, or did it
cut its losses after a series of missteps and expensive engineering
failures? And perhaps even more importantly: Are you going to choose a
vendor whose solutions box you in, or are you going to entrust your
future success to Sun, a systems powerhouse that offers you exceptional
choice and flexibility to maximize your investment protection and help
minimize your total cost of ownership?"
Customized news reports about Sun Microsystems. Just the news you need, none of what you don't. 50,000+ Members. 20,000+ Articles Published since 1998.